Is Rishabh Pant a better test wicketkeeper batsman than MS Dhoni?
Cricket fans and analysts often draw comparisons between players of different generations, especially when it comes to roles as pivotal as the wicketkeeper-batsman. In India, MS Dhoni set an exceptional benchmark, and now, Rishabh Pant is making his case to carry that legacy forward. While it may be too early for a definitive conclusion, a comparison of their Test cricket statistics gives us a glimpse of their contributions and potential. Lets see who is better between Rishabh Pant vs MS Dhoni.
MS Dhoni retired from Test cricket in 2014, and his absence left a massive void in the Indian team. However, Rishabh Pant has filled that gap admirably. With only 35 Tests to his name so far, Pant has already shown that he can handle the pressures of international cricket. His dual role as an aggressive batsman and a reliable wicketkeeper has added a new dimension to the Indian Test team.
While Dhoni’s legacy is firmly established, Pant still has a long career ahead of him, with plenty of opportunities to surpass Dhoni’s records and create his own legacy. Given his early success, it will be intriguing to see how far Pant can go and whether he can surpass Dhoni as India’s greatest wicketkeeper-batsman in Test cricket.
DOWNLOAD: STUMPSANDBAILS FANTASY CRICKET APP
Batting Comparison: A Tale of Two Styles
When it comes to batting, both Pant and Dhoni have left a significant mark in the longest format of the game. Dhoni amassed 4876 runs in 144 innings, including six centuries. His ability to bat in the lower middle order and his knack for guiding the tailenders were crucial to India’s success in several matches. Dhoni was known for his ability to absorb pressure and play calculated innings when the team needed stability.
Pant, in contrast, is known for his aggressive batting style. He has already scored 2419 runs in just 58 innings, matching Dhoni’s tally of six centuries. What sets Pant apart is his fearless approach to batting. While Dhoni was known for his resilience, Pant is known for his explosive ability to turn the game around with quick runs.
Pant’s strike rate in Tests is significantly higher than Dhoni’s, reflecting his intent to dominate bowlers. His memorable centuries in challenging overseas conditions, like the one in Australia, have cemented his reputation as a game-changer.
Wicketkeeping Prowess: Rishabh Pant vs MS Dhoni
As a wicketkeeper, MS Dhoni is widely regarded as one of the finest in the history of Indian cricket. Across 90 Test matches, Dhoni registered 294 dismissals, which includes 256 catches and 38 stumpings. His sharp reflexes behind the stumps and unorthodox style made him an integral part of the Indian Test side, particularly in challenging subcontinental conditions.
Rishabh Pant, on the other hand, has already established himself as India’s third most successful Test wicketkeeper with 134 dismissals (119 catches and 15 stumpings) in just 35 matches. While Dhoni’s experience and longevity give him the edge in terms of total dismissals, Pant’s numbers are impressive for a player still in the early stages of his career.
Pant’s athleticism and aggression in the field, coupled with his ability to adapt, make him a formidable force behind the stumps. Though Dhoni is known for his calm demeanor, Pant brings a more energetic and dynamic approach, showcasing a new style of wicketkeeping in Test cricket.
ALSO READ: Top 5 Teams With Most Wins in Test Cricket
Conclusion: Who is the Better Wicketkeeper Batter In Test Format
In the Dhoni vs Pant debate, it’s important to remember that the two players belong to different eras of Indian cricket. Dhoni was the calm, composed leader, while Pant was the fiery young talent. As of now, Dhoni remains the more accomplished wicketkeeper in terms of dismissals and match experience, but Pant’s aggressive batting and his rapid rise in the Test arena make him a strong contender for the title of the best Test wicketkeeper-batsman India has produced. So, the future holds great promise for Pant, and only time will tell whether he can surpass the heights reached by MS Dhoni
